Rock Island Auction Company
Back to Catalog
Auction Date: May 6, 2017

Lot 2152: James Reid .41 Caliber Knuckle Duster Revolver

Full Screen
Incredibly Rare Documented Factory Engraved James Reid .41 Caliber Knuckle Duster Revolver
Estimated Price: $25,000 - $40,000
Item Views 363 Bid Activity Average
Serial #James Reid .41 Caliber Knuckle Duster Revolver ManufacturerReid James ModelKnuckle Duster
TypeRevolver Gauge41 RF Catalog Page85
Barrel1 7/8 Inch Cylinder FinishSilver Plated GripSilver Plated Brass
Stock ClassAntique RatingSee Condition
DescriptionOnly an estimated 150 .41 caliber knuckle duster revolvers were manufactured in a two year span starting in the summer of 1870 by James Reid of Catskill, New York. They are among the rarest of all of Reid's revolvers. According to "James Reid and His Catskill Knuckledusters" by Taylor G. Bowen, this is the second earliest surviving example of only 16 known. It is also in outstanding condition even without comparing it to the relatively worn down others, and when compared with the others, it is truly exceptional and the finest known remaining. Most of Reid's revolvers spent considerable time in pockets and retain little to no original finish whereas this example retains nearly all of its beautifully aged silver plating. Bowen indicated most had silver plated frames and blued cylinders making this factory full silver finish particularly desirable. It has two groove front sights; one each at the front and back of the top strap which is marked with "JAMES REID'S DERRINGER/PATD. DEC. 26, 1865." A sliding safety is at the front of the frame at the bottom. The cylinder pin and rear cylinder face are marked with the matching partial serial number "40." The full serial number is located between the trigger and the mainspring compartment door on the floral engraved frame. Like all of Reid's knuckle dusters, the revolver could be used as a brass knuckle if six shots weren't enough to put down your assailants. He called them "Knucklers" or "My Friend." Even the largest models are small enough to easily be concealed in a pocket. Like many of America's gunmakers in the 19th century, James Reid (1827-1898) was an immigrant. He was born in Belfast, Ireland, and arrived in the U.S. with his family in 1857. After initially living in New York City, he resettled in Catskill where he established his gunshop and a grist mill and eventually employed 17 workers. According to Ann Gibbons, after economic turmoil in the 1870s and 1880s and increased competition from more advanced firearms, he moved to Troy in 1883 and is believed to have worked at the Watervliet Arsenal.

ConditionExcellent. 95% of the original silver plating remains. There is only some slight loss at the edges and around the engraving on the right side. The silver and brass have attractive aged patina throughout and especially dark patina on the right side of the frame. The cylinder and other iron parts have some light pitting and oxidation. The engraving and markings remain crisp, and it is mechanically excellent. Reportedly the finest .41 caliber Reid Knuckle Duster known!
Click here to see keyboard shortcuts.
F Enters/exits full screen view for items
Esc Exits full screen view for items
Moves to previous lot, or moves to previous image if full screen view is enabled
Moves to next lot, or moves to next image if full screen view is enabled
Fully zooms the image when full screen view is enabled
Fits the entire image to the screen when full screen view is enabled


Buyer’s Premium: 17.5%

Cash Payment Discount: 2.5%

Participation Requirements: Valid Credit Card required for bidding approval. You will have the option to pay with these payment options: Visa, MasterCard, Discover, Check, Money Order, Wire Transfer, and Cash.

Sales Tax: It varies each auction typically around 94% of auction items are not subject to sales tax. Read more here on sales tax.

We will contact you after the auction to arrange payment and shipping.


Premiere Auction Terms

Terms and conditions regarding Premiere Auctions. Revised : 08/29/2014


SHIPPING CHARGES. All shipping charges must be paid by the successful bidder prior to delivery of the firearm. If Rock Island Auction (RIAC) is asked to ship the purchased lots, there will be a separate charge for such shipping. Shipping charges will be based upon what it costs RIAC to ship the purchased lots to the purchaser. All items must have shipping insurance; this insurance is mandatory. RIAC will not charge any labor charges for shipping. RIAC is not liable for any acts of omissions in packaging or shipping. Purchased lots handled by outside carriers or packers, including those RIAC may have recommended, may carry their own insurance and any claims for losses or damages should be addressed directly to the outside carriers or packers. RIAC will arrange for packing and shipping at RIAC’s earliest possible convenience. RIAC will attempt to ship as soon as possible; however, due to RIAC’s high volume of absentee bids, shipping can take up to two weeks after full payment is received. In the case of crating or any exceptional packaging, the purchaser will be charged RIAC’s cost from outside agents. Purchaser pays shipping, packing materials, and insurance charges. The shipping of any purchased items outside of the United States is hereby classified as “foreign export”. All foreign export is the sole responsibility of the purchaser.