The accompanying factory letter states the revolver was shipped on October 1, 1875 and delivered to M.W. Robinson Co. of New York City with nickel finish and rosewood grips. This was a 200 gun shipment. The floral scroll engraving, back strap inscription and pearl grips were likely supplied by M.W. Robinson. The back strap is engraved with the name "W.E. ATWATER."

Exceptionally fine as period New York engraved, retaining 90% untouched original nickel finish with gray patina on the balance. The engraving is crisp. There is a small chip on the bottom of the right grip panel, otherwise the grips are fine with attractive fiery colors. Mechanically fine.