Rock Island Auction Company
Back to Catalog
Auction Date: September 10, 2017

Lot 3036: Winchester Model 1895 Carbine Presented by Buffalo Bill

Full Screen
Rare and Documented Factory Inscribed Winchester Model 1895 Lever Action Saddle Ring Carbine Presented by Wild West Showman Buffalo Bill (William F. Cody) to Fred Kavanaugh with Factory Letter
Estimated Price: $110,000 - $160,000
Item Views 1274 Bid Activity Average
Serial #Winchester Model 1895 Carbine Presented by Buffalo Bill ManufacturerWinchester Model1895-Carbine
TypeCarbine Gauge30-40 Krag Catalog Page36
Barrel22 Inch Round FinishBlue Grip
Stockwalnut ClassCurio & Relic Long Gun RatingSee Condition
DescriptionThis is a rare Winchester Model 1895 lever action carbine that is factory documented as presented by famed Wild West legend and showman William F. Cody aka Buffalo Bill to his friend New York State Senator Fred Kavanaugh. Cody used a Model 1895 on hunting expeditions, and he is known to have presented Model 1895s to friends. For other identified examples see R.L. Wilson's book "Buffalo Bill's Wild West: An American Legend" (pages 179 and 181). Another presentation Model 1895 was presented to Chief Plenty Coups of the Crow Nation by Prince Albert of Monaco. At the time, Prince Albert was visiting Cody, Wyoming, and hunting with Buffalo Bill. Although Buffalo Bill did not personally present the rifle to Chief Plenty Coups, film footage of the presentation shows Cody present at the ceremony, even holding the gun, which had an engraved plaque on the stock. Speaking to Buffalo Bill's generosity, former Senior Curator of the Buffalo Bill Historical Center Dr. Paul Fees stated, "[Buffalo Bill] is known to have made several gifts after 1895, all Winchesters. After 1895 he is known to have purchased and presented several Model 1895 Winchesters in .30 government or .405 caliber to adult friends." The factory letter lists the date of serialization as July 20, 1901 and confirms the carbine configuration, 30 caliber and inscription on the right side of the receiver. The carbine was received in warehouse on July 29, 1901 and shipped the next day to only be returned for repair on September 7, 1901. The inscription on the receiver reads, "FRED W. KAVANAUGH/FROM/COL. W.F. CODY 'BUFFALO BILL'/1901." The carbine is equipped with a pinned blade front sight and military style folding leaf rear sight with tangent base. A saddle ring staple with ring is mounted on the left side of the receiver. The left side of the receiver also has the long two-line address/patent information. The upper tang is marked "WINCHESTER/-MODEL 1895-." The carbine lacks a caliber marking. Mounted on a finger grooved forearm, handguard and straight grip stock of special varnished, extra grain walnut and fitted with crescent buttplate featuring a trapdoor (period bore pull through included). In 1883, Buffalo Bill founded "Buffalo Bill's Wild West", a circus-like extravaganza that toured widely for three decades in the United States and later throughout Europe. His legendary show was a highly popular form of late 19th century entertainment that featured Native Americans and cowboys performing elaborate productions, which helped to solidify the legend of the American Western Frontier that still resonates today. During its existence, the show featured performances by people who are forever synonymous with the Western frontier and include such notables as Buck Taylor "King of the Cowboys," Annie Oakley, Frank Butler, Sitting Bull, Johnny Baker "The Cowboy Kid," Rough Rider Billy McGinty, Pawnee Bill, Dr. William Frank Carver, Montana Frank and Calamity Jane. In the winter of 1886, the show was retooled for an impressive four act indoor performance at Madison Square Garden. Famed American novelist Mark Twain admitted, "[The show] brought vividly back the breezy wild life of the Great Plains and the Rocky Mountains, and stirred me like a war-song." In 1887, the show traveled to Europe. In all, Buffalo Bill’s Wild West toured Europe eight times. The first four tours occurred between 1887 and 1892 and the last four from 1902 to 1906, bringing to Europe an exotic form of American entertainment. Buffalo Bill was an international superstar. Speaking to Buffalo Bill's worldwide fame, Mark Twain stated, "It is often said on the other side of the water that none of the exhibitions which we send to England are purely and distinctly American. If you will take the Wild West show over there you can remove that reproach." Fred Kavanaugh (1871-1940) was born in Waterford, Saratoga County, New York, and worked in the family knitting mill, becoming partners with his brother after the death of their father. He gained an interest in politics and served as a New York state senator from 1921 to 1924. He also served as Saratoga County sheriff, Supervisor of the Town of Waterford, chaired the Saratoga County Republican Committee, president of First National Bank of Mechanicville, NY, and was active in fraternal organizations. In 1930, Kavanaugh deeded Second King's Island to the Boy Scouts. His connection to Buffalo Bill is linked to the Irma Hotel in Cody, Wyoming, that he co-owned with Buffalo Bill. The hotel was named after Buffalo Bill's daughter. Factory documented Buffalo Bill presentation firearms are rarely encountered.

ConditionExceptionally fine. The carbine retains 80% plus original blue finish showing thinning to a brown. There is an area of mild pitting on the barrel. The wood is fine with a long scratch and some minor handling marks. Mechanically excellent. An impeccably documented worthy piece of American history from the most famous Wild West showman of all time.
Click here to see keyboard shortcuts.
F Enters/exits full screen view for items
Esc Exits full screen view for items
Moves to previous lot, or moves to previous image if full screen view is enabled
Moves to next lot, or moves to next image if full screen view is enabled
Fully zooms the image when full screen view is enabled
Fits the entire image to the screen when full screen view is enabled


Buyer’s Premium: 17.5%

Cash Payment Discount: 2.5%

Participation Requirements: Valid Credit Card required for bidding approval. You will have the option to pay with these payment options: Visa, MasterCard, Discover, Check, Money Order, Wire Transfer, and Cash.

Sales Tax: It varies each auction typically around 94% of auction items are not subject to sales tax. Read more here on sales tax.

We will contact you after the auction to arrange payment and shipping.


Premiere Auction Terms

Terms and conditions regarding Premiere Auctions. Revised : 08/29/2014


SHIPPING CHARGES. All shipping charges must be paid by the successful bidder prior to delivery of the firearm. If Rock Island Auction (RIAC) is asked to ship the purchased lots, there will be a separate charge for such shipping. Shipping charges will be based upon what it costs RIAC to ship the purchased lots to the purchaser. All items must have shipping insurance; this insurance is mandatory. RIAC will not charge any labor charges for shipping. RIAC is not liable for any acts of omissions in packaging or shipping. Purchased lots handled by outside carriers or packers, including those RIAC may have recommended, may carry their own insurance and any claims for losses or damages should be addressed directly to the outside carriers or packers. RIAC will arrange for packing and shipping at RIAC’s earliest possible convenience. RIAC will attempt to ship as soon as possible; however, due to RIAC’s high volume of absentee bids, shipping can take up to two weeks after full payment is received. In the case of crating or any exceptional packaging, the purchaser will be charged RIAC’s cost from outside agents. Purchaser pays shipping, packing materials, and insurance charges. The shipping of any purchased items outside of the United States is hereby classified as “foreign export”. All foreign export is the sole responsibility of the purchaser.