Skip to main content
Rock Island Auction Company
AuctionsConsignmentLatestFAQAbout us
Log InCreate Account
Rock Island Auction CompanyRock Island Auction Company
Contact us
1-309-797-15001-800-238-8022[email protected]
Locations
Bedford, TX
3600 Harwood RoadBedford, Texas 76021, USA
Rock Island, IL
7819 42nd Street WestRock Island, Illinois 61201, USA
Hours
Monday - Friday8:00 a.m. - 5:00 p.m.
Navigation
AuctionsConsignmentLatestFAQAbout usAccount
More Info
Terms & ConditionsPrivacy PolicyJob postings & CareersOrder a catalogContact
Social media
© 2025 Rock Island Auction Company. RIAC believes that this website is accessible to the widest possible audience pursuant to the guidelines of the Americans with Disability Act. Click here for more information.
Healthcare Transparency in Coverage.
Disconnected
Unable to connect to live update server, attempting reconnection. If this persists, please try refreshing your browser.
Disconnected state indicated by at top of page. If you cannot see this icon, you are connected.
Rock Island Auction Company
Hello.
Please Log In, or .

Home
Auctions
Consignment
Latest
FAQ
About us

  • /Auctions...
  • /Catalog...
  • /Lot 1171

Lot 1171:"Famous American Frontier" Freund Sharps Model 1874 Rifle

June 6th, 2020|Rock Island, IL
  • /Auctions...
  • /Catalog...
  • /Lot 1171

Lot 1171:"Famous American Frontier" Freund Sharps Model 1874 Rifle

June 6th, 2020|Rock Island, IL
Price Realized:
Login to viewLogin to view
Price obfuscated
Estimated Price$40,000 - $60,000
Log In to use Wishlists
Share

Extraordinary Historic "Famous American Frontier" Inscribed and Engraved Freund Sharps Model 1874 Rifle with Scabbard, Factory Letter, and Documentation

This is believed to be the only Freund Sharps rifle with both Wyoming Armory and Durango, Colorado, markings. The accompanying factory letter (copy) based on the serial number on the bottom of the barrel lists this rifle with a 30 inch full octagon barrel in .45 2 7/8 caliber and double set triggers when invoiced December 8, 1877, to Sharp's largest dealer, Schuyler, Hartley and Graham of New York City. The rifle was returned to the factory and shipped to Sharp's dealer Nathaniel Curry and Brother of San Francisco and was in their inventory on August 2, 1879, with a 30 inch barrel and listed as .50 caliber. The caliber is almost certainly a records error as the rifle is still .45 caliber. Fruend is known to have shortened long barrels to create more convenient "saddle rifles" and likely shortened the barrel on this rifle for that purpose given its original owner was a cattleman. Also includes display boards and other informational items such as a research binder full of copies of documents and articles relating to the Freunds, including scans and transcriptions of letters to Sharps and the Freunds concerning rifles and ammunition. In one of the many included letters, Herman Hass wrote to Frank Freund stating in part that: "I have come to the conclusion that your rifle is equaled by none and that it is the best in world for strength, reliability, simplicity, and durability." This exact rifle is pictured and discussed on page 354 of "Freund & Bro.: Pioneer Gunmakers to the West" by Belentine where it is noted as "Probably originally worked on in Cheyenne, then taken to Durango, Colorado, where George Freund finished the engraving. From Carlisle Ranch in the Four Corners Area west of Durango; in original family for 103 years until purchased by present owner in 1985. (David Tawney Collection)." Based on the date of purchase listed on the display, the rifle would have been purchased two years after George Freund relocated to Durango and the partnership with his brother Frank had ended. The rifle has a Rocky Mountain style blade front sight, boxed "Old Reliable" and Sharps Bridgeport address ahead of the Freund "More Light" notch and folding ladder rear sight, "F.W. FREUND/PATENTED/AUG. 1st/1876/Jan. 2nd/1877/FREUND'S/PATENT/JUNE 29/1880/DURANGO/COLO" on top between the rear sight and the "CAL 45" marking, "2 7/8" on the right flat at the breech, "FAMOUS/AMERICAN/FRONTIER" inscribed on the right side of the action, "FREUNDS PAT WYOMING ARMORY CHEYENNE W.T." on the bottom of the lock, Freund pattern extended hammer spur, Freund improved breech block, double extractors, a silver banner installed on the top of the action, "GEO FREUND/MANUFACTURER/DEALER OF/FIRE ARMES/DURANGO/COLO" on the left side of the action, scroll and floral engraving, all outside screw heads floral engraved, double set triggers, carved horn accents at the nose and tail of the forend, Freund patent checkered detachable pistol grip with coordinating carved horn grip cap, silver initial shield behind the grip, checkered buttplate with sliding door, and takedown cleaning rod contained within the stock. The rifle scabbard has "ESC" hand marked on the right side under the handle. An included display board indicates the rifle was originally owned by English immigrant "Edmund Septimus Charlisle [sic]" who was born in Liverpool in 1851, moved to Mt. Hope, Kansas, in 1879, purchased this rifle in Durango from George Freund in 1882, worked at a ranch near Durango during the summer months, and died in Mt. Hope, Kansas, near Wichita in 1894. Both primary and secondary sources clearly indicate the Carlisle Brother's were far from seasonal ranch hands or average cowboys; they were in fact wealthy men and "extensive cattle and ranch owners." Edmund S. Carlisle is generally listed as living at the ranch at Mt. Hope and appears to have made it his home in 1886. He was in Durango regularly throughout the period. Harold Carlisle, Edmund's brother, is listed as living in Durango in the 1880s and later lived in Utah. Another brother, Thomas visited from England in 1888. The obituaries for Edmund S. Carlisle indicate at that time of his death in 1894 he owned a 2,000 acre ranch, studied at Oxford where he was a talented rower, served as an officer in the army in India, was a "thorough nimrod" (hunter), had three living children, and became an agent of a land syndicate around 1884 which owned land in New Mexico and Kansas as well as Colorado and Utah. Another article discussing his will notes that Edmund S. Carlisle was "one of the largest stockmen of the county." The company he ran with his brother was variously as the Kansas & New Mexico Land & Cattle Company, Carlisle Cattle Company, and Carlisle Brothers and exported some of their cattle to Europe. Many of their holdings helped them secure valuable water resources. Their expansive operations also brought them into conflict with local Native American nations such as the Utes and Paiutes. In at least one of these encounters in 1884, Edmund Carlisle was part of the group of ranchers and cowboys that exchanged shots with the warriors and then pursued them with help from the U.S. Army. Members of various regional tribes stole horses, killed cattle and sometime settlers, burned ranches, and generally terrorized those settling on their former lands in the 1880s. See "Cowboys, Indians and the Fight in White River Canyon" by Robert L. Foster for "Wild West Magazine" for more details. The Carlisle Bros. involvement made news in the East. Even our own local paper, The Rock Island Daily Argus, reported on Harold Carlisle's request for government intervention against the tribes in 1884. Carlisle's men also had violent exchanges with Mexican sheep herders from New Mexico in 1886 that included a day long siege by the Mexicans of some of Carlisle's men that left at least one Mexican herder dead, others wounded, and a $500 rewards for some of Carlisle's men proclaimed by the New Mexican governor despite their actions previously being declared self-defense at trial. At least three Mexican herders were reportedly killed by his men during this period. Given this rifle was built and purchased in the 1880s, it very well may have been used in some of those violent encounters on the range.

ConditionFine with 50% plus blue finish, strong original case colors in the protected areas, crisp engraving and markings, some minor spotting, and general mild wear consistent with age and frontier use. The wood is also fine and has even oiled finish, some scrapes and pressure marks, and minor edge wear. Mechanically excellent. The scabbard is very good with supple leather, some crackling and creasing, a tear at the flap fold, and rub wear. This is an incredible, example of George Freund's work on Sharp rifles made all the more exciting its connection to western frontier history. A collection in and of itself.
Details
ManufacturerSharps Rifle Manufacturing Company
Model1874-Rifle
TypeRifle
Serial number
ClassAntique
Caliber / Gauge45 2 7/8
Barrel24 1/4 inch octagon
Finishblue/casehardened
Stockwalnut

Item LocationRock Island, IL
Views2538
Catalog page124
Find MoreRelated Items
Lot 3101"Frontier Issued" Sharps 1874 Sporting Rifle with Scope
View Lot
Lot 1064Sharps Bridgeport 1874 Mid-Range No. 1 Target Rifle
View Lot
Lot 1168Factory Engraved/Inscribed Colt Bisley Model Revolver
View Lot
Lot 3084Sharps Model 1874 Single Shot "Buffalo" Rifle in .45-70 Gov.
View Lot
Show More