Skip to main content
Rock Island Auction Company
AuctionsConsignmentBlogFAQNewsAbout Us
Create Account
Login
AuctionsConsignmentBlogFAQNews & EventsAbout Us
Login
Create Account

History Lives Here

Rock Island Auction Company
1-309-797-15001-800-238-8022[email protected]
RIAC Rock Island
7819 42nd Street West
Rock Island, Illinois 61201, USA
8:00am - 5:00pm, Mon - Fri
RIAC Bedford
3600 Harwood Road
Bedford, Texas 76021, USA
8:00am - 5:00pm, Mon - Fri
Navigation
  • Auctions
  • Consignment
  • Blog
  • FAQ
  • News
  • About Us
More Info
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Job Postings & Careers
  • Contact
  • Order a Catalog
© 2025 Rock Island Auction Company. RIAC believes that this website is accessible to the widest possible audience pursuant to the guidelines of the Americans with Disability Act. Click here for more information.
Healthcare Transparency in Coverage.
  • Auction Catalog #89
  • Lot #3105
Lot #3104
Lot #3106

Lot 3105: Crimean War Sam Colt Presentation Cased Colt 1851 Navy Revolvers

Rare, Documented, Historic Crimean War Cased Factory Engraved Colt Model 1851 London Navy Percussion Revolvers with Presentation Inscriptions to French General Pelissier from "the Inventor" Samuel Colt Featured in "The Colt Engraving Book, Volume 1" by R.L. Wilson

Auction Location: Rock Island, IL

Auction Date: August 27, 2023

Lot 3105: Crimean War Sam Colt Presentation Cased Colt 1851 Navy Revolvers

Rare, Documented, Historic Crimean War Cased Factory Engraved Colt Model 1851 London Navy Percussion Revolvers with Presentation Inscriptions to French General Pelissier from "the Inventor" Samuel Colt Featured in "The Colt Engraving Book, Volume 1" by R.L. Wilson

Auction Location: Rock Island, IL

Auction Date: August 27, 2023

Estimated Price: $75,000 - $125,000

A) Colt Model 1851 Navy Revolver

Manufacturer: Colt
Model: 1851 Navy
Type: Revolver
Gauge: 36
Barrel: 7 1/2 inch octagon
Finish: blue/casehardened/silver
Grip: walnut
Stock:
Item Views: 1961
Item Interest: Active
Serial Number:
Catalog Page: 94
Class: Antique
Description:

This cased pair of Colt Model 1851 London Navy Revolvers was manufactured in 1854 and features historic presentation inscriptions on the back straps reading: "Genl Pelissier/from the Inventor." The case lid is also inscribed "Gen Pelissier,/from the Inventor." The revolvers are illustrated on page 228 of "The Colt Engraving Book Volume 1" by R.L. Wilson where Wilson notes that "colonel Colt correspondence with Pelissier exists, in the Wadsworth Athenaeum collection of approximately fifty letters and other documents, involving VIPs with whom Colonel Colt had friendships, or business or social associations. Pelissier was a major figure in the French involvement in the Crimean War. The Colonel's intentions of building an armory in France are considered to have been instrumental in Colt's judiciously placed presentation arms, to figures like Pelissier, and The Emperor, Napoleon III." The Pelissier presentation Colts are contemporaries of the cased pairs of Model 1851 Navy revolvers presented to French Emperor Napoleon III sold by Rock Island Auction Co. in 2019 and the cased pair sold to Lord Cardigan, British Commander of the Light Brigade, sold by Rock Island Auction Co. in 2021 for $184,000. The famous Charge of the Light Brigade occurred on October 25th, 1854 during the Crimean War. The recipient of this exquisite set of cased presentation Colt London Navy revolvers, French General Aimable-Jean-Jacques Pelissier (1794-1864), one of the most powerful and influential figures in France in the mid-19th century, took command of an army corps in January of 1855, took command of the French forces at Sevastopol in May of 1855 and very quickly made his presence known, going as far as defying orders of Napoleon III in order to secure victories, and successfully captured the important port city on the Black Sea after his men took the Tower of Malakoff. He was subsequently promoted to the highest rank as Marshal of France and Duke of Malakoff as rewards. The latter was the only victory title bestowed during Napoleon III's reign. General Aimable-Jean-Jacques Pelissier had been an officer since 1815 and had risen from a second lieutenant in the artillery that year to a major-general (general de division) by 1850 and military commander of Oran. By that time he had been shown to be ruthless and is noted to have ordered mass executions of resisting tribal peoples in Algeria, including driving the Ouled Riah tribe from their settlements and then suffocating them in caves in 1845 which on one hand earned him public scrutiny but also led to him being promoted to brigadier-general. He was the interim governor of Algeria in 1852 during Napoleon III's coup d'etat. Pelissier was also the vice president of the French Senate, a Member of the Privy Counsel, Commander in Chief of the Army of the East, Grand Chancellor of the Legion of Honor, and Governor General of Algeria. Pelissier was in London as the French ambassador from March 1858 to April 1859 before returning to Algeria where he was Governor General until his death in Algiers in 1864. The presentation of these London Navy revolvers is documented in period correspondence between Samuel Colt and Henry Pelham Fiennes Pelham-Clinton, the Fifth Duke of Newcastle, active as Secretary of War for Britain between June 12th, 1854-January 30th, 1855, whom Colt had personally present the revolvers to General Aimable-Jean-Jacques Pelissier "in the field of battle" in August of 1855, during the Siege of Sevastopol. Samuel Colt originally commissioned these revolvers to be made specially for General Pelissier due to Colt's strong admiration of him. Samuel Colt had friends in "high places," and his connection to the Duke of Newcastle was critical in the assurance of delivery of these special revolvers. Upon presentation of the revolvers, the Duke of Newcastle wrote a signed letter to Samuel Colt, "I had the pleasure of presenting in your name to General Pelissier a few days ago the brace of revolvers which you entrusted with me. He seemed much pleased by the compliment you have paid him, and I have no doubt he will have written to thank you. The battle two days ago was a brilliant affair on the part of the French and the Sardinians. The Russians attacked a strong position very gallantly." The battle referenced in the Duke of Newcastle's letter was the Russian attack at the Battle of Chernaya on August 16th, 1855, in which the outnumbered combined forces of the French Empire and the Kingdom of Sardinia (approximately 36,000) met the inexperienced forces of the Russian Empire (approximately 58,000) with stiff resistance and emerged victorious under French command of General Pelissier. The combined French and Sardinian forces suffered only less than 300 deaths and less than 1,600 wounded, while the defeated Russians suffered over 3,300 deaths, over 3,300 wounded, some sources state as many as 7,000 wounded, and 1,500 were captured. Tsar Alexander had plans for a Russian victory in order to negotiate a peace with favorable terms, and instead the Russian Empire was humiliated greatly by the loss. It is considered to be one of the greatest victories in history, owed greatly to the brilliant strategy of General Pelissier, considered to be the hero of France for his successful efforts. Four days after the Battle of Chernaya on August 16th, 1855, and three days after the subsequent Fifth Bombardment of Sevastopol on August 17th, 1855 in which the city of Sevastopol was captured, General Pelissier wrote a letter of appreciation to Samuel Colt, dated August 20th, 1855, that states, "Colonel, His Grace, the Duke of Newcastle, has had the kindness to send me the two pistols that you have had the extreme goodness to offer me. I accept your present and thank you for having sent these beautiful arms, in which you display such rare skill and great perfection. Those of my officers who are occupied specially with firearms have admired them much. I am extremely touched by this cordial homage and I pray you to receive my distinguished assurance." The news of Sevastopol's fall reached France on September 8th, 1855, and Paris erupted in celebration, with French national honor appeased. For his perseverance and heroism, Aimable Pelissier was promoted to the highest rank as Marshal of France. This presentation set of revolvers is further documented as publicized throughout Europe in "The American" newspaper, printed in Paris on October 6th, 1855, in which it proudly states, "The distinguished French Commander in Chief of the Crimea, Marshal Pelissier, has recently received from Colonel Colt a present of a beautiful pair of his World renowned Revolver: We have much pleasure in publishing the courteous reply from the Marshal, which will no doubt be perused with much satisfaction." and proceeds to quote the aforementioned August 20th dated letter written by Pelissier. Another American newspaper titled "Daily American Organ" also records the presentation of the revolvers as published on October 11th, 1855 in which it has the excerpt, "From the Hartford (Ct.) Times. Colt's Pistols in the Crimea." and states, "While he was in London, Colonel Colt sent out a pair of his famous revolving pistols as a present to General (now Marshal) Pelissier. The veteran soldier replied to Colonel Colt in the note copied below:" and has another excerpt, "From the London Morning Advertiser. Letter from General Pelissier." that states, "The following letter has been received from General Pelissier, in acknowledgement of a pair of Colt's revolvers, sent to him as a present by the inventor. It may not be inappropriate to state, since we so strongly recommend the adoption of this arm, that General Shirley, as well as other distinguished officers, have stated that not one of the accidents which have happened from the use of revolvers in the Crimea has been traced to Colt arms. Our own government has lately given an additional order for upward of nine thousand, and it could be wished that all these had arrived in the Crimea in time for the late glorious attack." In the 1850s as his firearms business based in Hartford, Connecticut, took off and made him a wealthy man, Samuel Colt courted various European powers looking to expand his business in Europe. The Crimean War in 1853-1856 represented an excellent opportunity for Colt to sell large quantities of revolvers and prove to Europeans that his revolvers were excellent sidearms for military service, especially his popular Model 1851 Navy revolvers. 5,000 of these Colt London manufactured Navy revolvers were purchased for use by the U.K. Royal Army during the war, but Colt faced stiff competition in the U.K. and ultimately lost out to the innovative and more powerful double action Beaumont-Adams revolvers which ultimately forced the closure of his factory in London after it had manufactured around 42,000 of these Model 1851 Navy revolvers for the European market in 1853-1857. French officers were still largely armed with single shot pistols at the time which represented a real opportunity for Colt. The Crimean War involved a massive number of men, in which the British and French joined forces with Turkey to declare war on the Russian Empire. The French force alone totaled over 309,000 men. The conflict was closely watched by international observers as it marked a new period in warfare as rifles became the standard infantry arms and artillery became increasingly more powerful. If he was able to secure significant contracts with a Continental European power like France, Colt could significantly expand his business, but, to do so, he needed influential figures like General Pelissier on his side. He presented them fine revolvers like these to make them familiar with his arms and to help grease the wheels. This matched pair of closely serialized 2nd Model Colt London Navy Revolvers have blued barrels and cylinders, casehardened loading levers, frames and hammers, and iron, silver-plated trigger guards and backstraps. The revolvers are fitted with deluxe, highly figured, piano-finished, walnut grips. The revolvers are embellished with delicate, English vine style scroll engraving on the barrel muzzles, top flats and lugs, the sides and bottoms of the loading levers, the frames, hammer tops and sides, trigger guards, and back straps. The top of the barrels are roll-stamped: "-ADDRESS COL. COLT. LONDON-" in one line surrounded by engraved panels. "COLTS PATENT" is engraved in Old English script in ribbons on the left sides of the frames. The cylinders of both revolvers are roll-engraved with the Naval Battle of Campeche scene and "COLTS PATENT." The full serial number is stamped on the loading lever, barrel, frame, trigger guard back strap and cylinder of each revolver. Punch-marks below the serial numbers on the barrels, frames, trigger guards, and back straps denote that the revolvers were designated at the factory for engraving and special finish. All of the visible serial numbers on both revolvers match. The London proof and view marks are stamped on the left side of both barrel lugs and cylinders. The revolvers have an oak, brass-bound, English style case with green lining. The case lid is inlaid with a circular, brass, folding, handle surrounding a round brass disk inscribed: "Genl Pelissier,/from the Inventor." The case contains a steel cleaning rod with turned wooden handle, two blued iron double-cavity bullet molds for round balls and conical bullets marked "COLTS/PATENT" on the sprue cutters, two blued nipple wrench/screw-driver combination tools, lead .36 caliber round balls and conical bullets, two Eley Bros. percussion cap tins with green paper labels, and a bag-shaped English powder flask with gold-plated brass top marked: "JAMES. DIXON/& SONS/SHEFFIELD," an adjustable spout, and brown lacquer body. Also with the pair is a large brass memorial medallion with the bust of Pelissier on the front and list of offices and positions he held and a British Crimean War campaign medal with a bust of Queen Victoria on the front marked "CRIMEA" and a Roman warrior receiving a laurel crown from Victory on the reverse along with the proper pale blue ribbon with yellow edges with three oak leaf clasps noting the battles of Sebastopol, Inkermann, and Alma.

Rating Definition:

Fine. The revolver has significant amounts of the original, high polish, blue finish in the protected areas of the barrel and retains 40% of the original blue finish on the cylinder. Nearly all of the roll-engraved battle scene on the cylinder is visible. The frame, loading lever, and hammer retain approximately half of the casehardened finish. About 20% of the delicate silver-plated finish remains on the trigger guard and back strap. The revolver has some scattered patches of pitting. The English scroll engraving is crisp. The barrel address, patent markings, serial numbers, proofs, and the inscription are sharp. The deluxe grip is very fine and retains nearly all of the high gloss varnish finish, and shows only minor storage wear. Mechanically fine. The case is fine and shows minor storage wear on the exterior and clean and bright lining with limited minor tears from the front sights and hammers. All of the accessories are fine. The powder flask retains 95% of the brown lacquer finish on the body and 85% of the gold-plated finish on the spout and top.



B) Colt Model 1851 Navy Revolver

Manufacturer: Colt
Model: 1851 Navy
Type: Revolver
Gauge: 36
Barrel: 7 1/2 inch octagon
Finish: blue/casehardened/silver
Grip: walnut
Stock:
Item Views: 1961
Serial Number:
Catalog Page: 517
Class: Antique
Description:

See "A." Provenance: General A.J.J. Pelissier, 1st Duc de Malakoff and Marshal of France; The Raymond Kendall Collection; The John Fielder Collection; The Norm Vegely Collection

Rating Definition:

Fine. The barrel retains 30% of the original, high polish blue finish in the protected areas. The frame, loading lever, and hammer retain approximately half of the casehardened finish with strong case colors on the loading lever and side of the frame. 20% of the delicate, silver-plated finish remains on the trigger guard and back strap. There are areas of mild pitting. The engraving, markings, and inscriptions are distinct. The grip is excellent and retains nearly all of the high gloss varnish finish and has minor storage wear. The hammer does not hold at half-cock, but the revolver is otherwise mechanically fine. This set of Samuel Colt Crimean War presentation revolvers is historically significant and incredibly rare. Only a few pairs of Colt London Navy revolvers with presentation inscriptions are known, and this pair was owned by the French commander in chief as presented on the battlefield at the famous Siege of Sevastopol during the Crimean War: General A.J.J. Pelissier.



Customer Product Questions

There are currently no customer product questions on this lot

    Related Items

    Lot #1390: Colt Factory Archive Example Stainless Model 1851 Navy Revolver

    Lot #628: Colt Model 1851 Navy Percussion Revolver

    Lot #1469: Collection of Sporting Books

    Lot #663: Powder Horn Commemorating General James Wolfe

    Lot #650: Engraved Powder Horn with "Caleb Webb Boston" and "Roxbury 1775"

    Lot #603: Colt Model 1851 Navy Percussion Revolver